Should I contract through a PAYE agency or as a sole trader in New Zealand?
A PAYE agency (umbrella) runs your income through payroll exactly like an employee: IRD income tax, the 1.75% ACC Earner's Levy, and KiwiSaver are deducted automatically, and the agency handles GST and invoicing if you're below the threshold. A sole trader invoices clients directly, deducts genuine business expenses before tax, and pays their own ACC levy (which includes an industry-rated Work Levy on top of the Earner's Levy component), but carries more admin and no automatic KiwiSaver contribution. At most day rates the two structures land close on tax; the real trade-off is admin overhead versus deductible expenses.